Eclectic astrology enthusiast and amateur historian of astrology. Big on textual comparisons, lists and spreadsheets. AKA that guy who made that big list of lots.
Since I teach astronomy, many astrologers are confused when I tell them I use Whole Sign Houses exclusively in my practice. There seems to be collective (mis)understandings that as a system, Whole trades mathematical accuracy for rounded efficiency. However, I'd like to make the case that Whole is, in fact, astronomically accurate.
Part I. The Nonagesimal M
Ask an astrologer to define the M, and they'll describe it as something like the "highest point of the ecliptic above you,” and explain how its themes of legacy, along with those of the 10th house, career, public view, government, are derived from this astronomical feature of the M, being above everything else.
By default, nearly every chart-generating software (including most Whole calculators!) defines the M as the point where the Ecliptic is intersected by the Meridian, the line formed by tracing exactly North to South through the local Zenith. We’ll call this the “Meridian M”. However, for 99% of each day, this is *not* the highest section of the Ecliptic.
That honor goes instead to the point exactly 90° square to the horizon, the “Nonagesimal M”. This is geometrically simple; on a semi-circle, the furthest point of the curve from the bisecting line is perpendicular to that line. A planet 90° above the horizon is higher above you than one at the Meridian. So, calculating the M here is astronomically valid, and represents the 10th cusp in Whole, Equal, and Vehlow House systems, where it is perpetually in the 10th.
(The Meridian M communicates something different: the Meridian is where any particular degree culminates. But while that degree is experiencing its own highest point above the horizon, this does not conclusively define it as a house-cusp. I would argue that the Meridian M is more like the Vertex, which is a worthwhile point derived from Great Circles, but not a marker of a house.)
Peep the difference between Venus & Mercury in today's example chart.
Hesiod says Demeter gave birth to “Wealth,” which the footnote explicitly indicates “grain stores rather than money.”
This offers vital perspective on the second house’s connection to bodily nourishment and tangible goods.
“Wealth, a goodly god, who goes all over the earth and broad back of the sea, and whoever encounters him, into whosever hands he comes, he makes him rich and bestows much fortune* upon him.”
The son of Demeter goddess of the grain and agriculture, offers security of food stores.
Lastly, this idea of fortune also aligns with the nocturnal hemisphere of the chart — the sector associated with the Moon, the body and with fortune.
I'm a devout follower of Robert Hand's "astrology is a language" model. That doesn't mean anything goes - cats running across the keyboard aren't saying anything (OR ARE THEY?!). What it does is allow for a plurality of astrologies without having to prove or disprove one or the other.
"It works for me" is a tired excuse for why to use or not use a technique, but there may be a kernel of truth there. I truly believe we're in dialogue with the techniques. Maybe some of them just aren't speaking to you, but they'll happily talk to someone else. For example, I find a never get very helpful info from the Hermetic Lots. Doesn't mean they're invalid. Maybe my brain and/or spirit isn't wired right for them.