Astrology, Darling

Hybrid Astrology

An Astrological Existential Conundrum

TraditionalModern
=Dani ᥫ᭡November 20, 20266 min read

It started with the first episode of “A Lotta Fortune: A Cosmic Podcast”. A premiere episode on Venus, and the Venus Star Point. The research was scientific, and the delineation, coupled with historical trends, was profound - but then I got to the chapter about the Scorpio Venus Star Point, and paused. It had a lot of Pluto rulership references. Oops. Then we did an episode on Scorpio: the mythology and foundation. In my notes, I began writing about the three phases of Scorpio: the Scorpion, the Eagle, and the Phoenix, and stopped dead in my tracks. Oops again. These are Modern techniques and philosophies, and I’m a Traditional Astrologer now.

My astrology journey started twenty years ago, on Chicago’s North side in Roger’s Park - with a massive book called “Sextrology” by Stella Starsky & Quinn Cox. My roommates and I called it the “red bible”, because it was on our coffee table, and I was always reading aloud from it, informing any and all visitors of their Sun sign, and the mythology and lore associated with that sign. Years later, I’m realizing how much Modern astrology is woven into my astrological journey.

During the pandemic, I had a relapse, and was diagnosed with Tumefactive Multiple Sclerosis after a stint in the hospital. I was devastated by the aphasia, and cognitive debilitation. As a Gemini with a Virgo Moon - it seemed like a personal attack on my very identity. I wanted to know where in the sky this event was hiding. In my search I found Adam Elenbaas on YouTube, and signed up for Year One of Hellenistic Astrology. I learned about Project Hindsight, and the difference between Ancient and Modern Astrology, and I was an immediate convert. The shift from psychological interpretations and spiritual progression, to fortune and fate, was compelling; I had a chronic illness, and the last twenty years had been a roller-coaster of highs and lows - I wanted my astrology practice to acknowledge and address the harsh realities of life.

The Traditional rulership was the second reason: I had always felt inclined to roll my eyes every time an Aquarius referenced Uranus. Or aliens. The Modern perspective of rulership never clicked for me, it just seemed like the outer planets were too far, and too slow to be rulers of any sign. The Thema Mundi made my heart sing with its simplicity. The profound rationale for Traditional planets ruling two signs each, and one sign per luminary just fit. The red bible held the philosophy of 24 signs, each sign manifesting in a different way based on gender, which was groundbreaking at the time, but ultimately outdated. Each planet ruling a yang, or diurnal sign - and a yin, nocturnal sign was a more cohesive strategy for rulership, and I was easily converted on that front.

This year I launched a podcast with my bestie Natty, and we are both Traditional astrologers. We are ten episodes in, and along the way I’ve compiled a list of Modern astrological theories that I’d like to briefly investigate. Understanding their origin is just as imperative as learning Ancient Astrology practices, because we are at the precipice of a new Astrological era. We have knowledge of what was lost in translation, coupled with the Modern interpretations of what persevered through centuries. It is up to us to establish a new hybrid of Astrology that honors the new truth that emerges.

Modern Rulership - Uranus/Aquarius

Origin - Alan Leo is the father of Modern Rulership; but he is more of a spokesperson for the Collective of astrologers of the late 19th Century. Volume I of “The Astrologer’s Magazine”, released in 1890, contains an essay titled “Herschel’s Influence”. Herschel was the first name assigned to Uranus, as it was William Herschel who discovered Uranus. Alan Leo considers the new planet and he states:

“No planet deserves more attention or closely watching than the planet (Uranus). His power when in an angle is so great and the events promised by directions are of such sudden and unexpected nature, that all aspects to him should be especially noticed…”

Uranus, discovered in 1781, had just over 100 years of observation by the time of this publication. He is authoritative in stating:

“(Uranus) has no house of his own, but is said to have power in (Scorpio).

In the airy signs he refines the native’s intellect, gives keen perceptive qualities, and great leaning towards occult philosophies, and strong inclination towards the spiritual.

In the watery signs he is by no means so good, and in the fiery signs he is better than in the earthy.”

In this early publication, he ponders Uranus’ domicile loosely, observing Uranus’ affinity for air. This would evolve into a supposition that Uranus finds its domicile in Aquarius, by 1912:

“Uranus is by many astrologers associated with Saturn’s day sign, Aquarius” (pg. 100, The Art of Synthesis, Alan Leo).

Traditional Take - The discovery of Uranus, formerly known as “Herschel”, was centuries later. The care with which Alan Leo and his colleagues studied the planet was admirable, and finding a domicile for the trans-personal planets seems appropriate - but the Thema Mundi is so strong in reasoning. The Outer planets need not disrupt the original rulerships, in order to find a place of ease and power within the Zodiac.

The Zodiac as Man’s Journey

Origin - Psychological Movement: Piaget, Erikson, and Kohlberg explored the developmental phases of human growth, and Modern Astrologers/Psychologists noticed synchronicity with the Zodiac, and aligned each phase with a Zodiac sign. Aries represents age 0 - 2 years, Pisces represents 77 - 90 years.

Traditional Take - This seems like a legitimate Modern theory. Saturn, the planet of time and boundaries, rules Capricorn and Aquarius, giving them themes of aging. Jupiter, the planet of belief as the final sign’s Ruler, at the precipice of what is beyond this life, seems appropriate. William Lily on page 64 of Christian Astrology assigns Jupiter to middle age, but also “of a full judgement, or discretion”.

Zodiac Mottos

Origin - The Mottos of the Zodiac address the progression of Man from a theosophical perspective. Alan Leo is attributed with the vast shift from fate and fortune telling, to the psychological paradigm that Modern Astrologers operate in. Beginning with Aries as “I am” - representing the initial acknowledgement of life, and ending with Pisces as “I believe”.

Traditional Take - 2nd Century Astrologer Vettius Valens says of Aries: “powerful men are born, those having the say over life and death” (Valens, Anthologies, Chapter 1, Mark T. Riley). Of Jupiter-ruled Natives, William Lilly assigns: “Then is he magnanimous, faithful, bashful, aspiring in an honourable way at high matters…” (Lilly, Christian Astrology, pg. 62, Mark T. Riley). The mottos began as a shorthand way of consolidating the theme of a sign into two words. I think Modern Astrologers got it right, even if they are ultimately limiting.

Black Moon Lilith

Origin - Dom Neroman, a French Astrologer in 1937, first proposed the point of the Moon’s Apogee, or farthest point, as a representation of the occult, and what lies beneath the psyche. Prior to Neroman, Lilith had been assigned as both, an asteroid, and a supposed “ghost Moon”. The themes were similarly shadowy in both cases. Following its 1937 debut, Lilith saw a resurgence of focus in the 1950-60’s in the United States.

Evolution - In 1961, Ivy Goldstein-Jacobson took Lilith back to the ghost Moon concept. She tracked what its movements would be, based on the original calculations of an Astrologer named Sepharial, in 1918. She emphasized shadow work from a feminist perspective, of raw truth, and embracing the discomfort of facing yourself. She also confused Lilith completely: the French still had their “Black Moon Lilith”, which was the Moon’s furthest point - while Ivy Goldstein-Jacobson popularized “Dark Moon Lilith” as the echoes of a Ghost Moon.

Traditional Take - Lilith was not discovered until after the time of the Ancients. The confusion over points, however, brings Lots (Arabic Parts) to mind. There were variations on their calculations, and new Lots being proposed over time. Across distant regions. Still, it seems that Saturn holds enough shadow, and the whole concept of Lilith seems overwrought.

Stay tuned for Part II of Modern Astrology concepts, or comment one below that we should investigate next.

Sign in to join the conversation.