Ba430 Views
Post
@wordwitcher
Join the conversation. Sign in to reply.
37 replies
- L
Wyn@winterastrologyBa
im very open with my chart, and have had some 'astromages' try to attack me. some weird twitter stuff this past year lol. but as a witch before an astrologer, i'd say you are in no more danger magically with your chart out there than you are keeping it secret. someone who's decided to be your enemy doesn't need a chart to do damage in the slightest if that makes sense. but i'm also an open book. i think the worst people can do, personally for my own like comfort, is read a lot into your life through your chart. I didn't share my chart or even get a reading from an astrologer until i was out of my abusive relationship, because i was afraid of what people would see and i wasn't ready to heal that trauma yet. When you post your chart to a social media site made for astrologers, you know many may be able to read parts of your life you arn't open about publicly and i think that is valid. A lot of us have things we don't want to talk about lol With clients, they trust us to keep their information private, so i hope they would be comfortable with us keeping ours private as well <3CLauren Alexandra@wordwitcherBa
@winterastrology this is an understandable perspective. I suppose I'm also talking about people that don't share any placements but ask about others. And I do recognize that other people are free to say no or not share. It's an atypical and incomplete social contract with astrologers because this has never been an option until social media. I do agree about the client portion for sure. You also raise an interesting point about people commenting on and going into parts of our chart that we aren't comfortable with. I think that is a separate but related ethical discussion about unsolicited reading and delineation on someone's chart, which many astrologers struggle to stop themselves from doing, even if they don't verbalize the interpretation. Regarding astrological Magic though, the chart is a hell of a taglock. People can of course use other things, but it is a strong agent and one that can allow them to time the workings so I do think caution there is understandable.LWyn@winterastrologyBa
@wordwitcher 100% agree with all you said. i will also say protection is key for magic. when i was under astro-mage attacks i didn't need to use astrological magic for protection, just my usual witch stuff. so i can see how a chart can be useful for 'aiming' or 'planning' but i don't think it necessarily makes magic stronger outside of the preciseness of the spells. they were very targeted when it happened to me š„² so it was clear the person was using my chart. i normally do a nice little protection candle each week now lol.FJessica Lloyce@jessicalloyceworldBa
@winterastrology I appreciate this perspective. Fellow witch here as well and my main thing about not wanting to publicly share my chart isnāt so much about other people doing some ooga booga on me but more so attempting to 1. Thinking they know me when they donāt or 2. attempting to be manipulative with how they might approach me with something (like how you might talk to someone one way with a earth Venus vs another way with an fire Venus to get what you want out of them or out of the conversation). Now obviously thatās when my own discernment is supposed to kick in to weed out the weirdos, but I also donāt want to give people potential ammo to think they can be weird with you know?CGray@graygarlandBa
@winterastrology really nice to hear your experience on it. i totally understand not wanting to invite that as an astrologer trying to run my business online lol. like i have enough issues without ppl launching targeted attacks using the map of my soul lmaoLWyn@winterastrologyBa
@graygarland 100% lol with my experience i totally understand why people keep their charts secret, on the other end it's like if someone wants to harm you they will anyways. it reminds me of the saying locked doors just keep honest people honest, or something along those lines. but yea targeted magical attacks aren't something i'd wish even on my enemies lol they definitely always mess with business tooCGray@graygarlandBa
@winterastrology yesss that's so true. and when you put it that way it just makes me think of other supports we have online to protect ourselvesālike blocking, muting words or topicsāwhen we don't have a lot of capacity for exposure. and that's why i feel like i wouldn't necessarily feel more or less comfortable with an astrologer or a teacher based on whether they share their chart with me or anyone else. we don't have to know each other in that way to have an intimate and honest and fully reciprocal relationship.LWyn@winterastrologyBa
@graygarland 100%, this is something i've navigated with clients in my day job forever. just mutual respect for boundaries, and blocking when they are crossed should be the minimum spiritual protection <3 one thing i disliked about the direction of twitter, was people you blocked could still see everything you posted. my clients in SW respect my boundaries around personal information, and if they didn't i'd block them.i have the same respect for them, i don't ask them for information unless they freely offer it on their own will. i see approaching client work with astrology in the same way. even when we read for clients, they may let us know topics they don't want to delve into, and having a safe place for a client where they can keep parts of their life out of discussion is just as important in the dynamic during a reading. sorry im a little baked rn and went on a long ramble lmao but your comment inspired me to compare the boundaries i have with both clientele lol. and how sw boundaries affect my approach to astrology boundaries.CGray@graygarlandBa
@winterastrology itās a very good comparison!! haha. i had no idea twitter did that with the block function omg šµāš« - =
Anca
@the_millennial_croneBaNice point. I would argue that it is less unethical than it is slightly dishonest, when it comes to clients. There is a degree of reciprocity when working with clients (regardless of sector), where I as a provider have to be open to share a part of myself which is relevant (!). What I share in public and with whom, that is another question to me, though.CLauren Alexandra@wordwitcherBa
@the_millennial_crone this is interesting to think about. When it comes to being a practitioner and provider, there is also something of boundaries in place. We aren't supposed to know everything about our doctor. I suppose when I vacillate on the subject, I am more thinking about those who never share their charts but walk amongst and collect the charts of those who do. That's part of why I think about ethics and fairness, and the tension between individual liberty and social obligation.=Anca
@the_millennial_croneBa@wordwitcher indeed, but boundaries are not walls and that's why I emphasise relevance. When I teach or treat voice, for example, I am fairly open about how I suffered from a voice disorder myself and how I am also not always in the best place vocally - despite knowing an awful lot about how to counteract. And this ties neatly into your argument about gathering information but never giving it freely. I cannot expect vulnerability from others, which I do when I want them to hear me, and not be ready to be vulnerable myself. Someone who does that, might be called a predator (is that my iCoE or my saturnian B talking?) which would make your point very VERY valid.CLauren Alexandra@wordwitcherBa
@the_millennial_crone oh, to be clear, I definitely agree with you. My favorite metaphor for boundaries comes from an old infographic that shows how bad boundaries are absent around a stick figure, and too harsh of boundaries are a solid line, but healthy boundaries are a dashed line, allowing some things in and keeping some things out. I am a big teacher from experience myself, and believe strongly in the power of story and sharing. But yes, there can be a form of predation and power-over hierarchical maneuvering in one-sided chart collection while never sharing. It also only lets one person make synastry choices. As an aside I'm laughing because I just noticed I started this fight and the moon moved into Aries š - J
Thempowered Astrology + Cocreating@thempoweredBa
im very pro astrologers that share their birth charts and respect the ways they choose to. it grinds against my values to learn from or listen to astrologers that conceal their chart info. i dont have my my chart visible here (yet) but i publically use it on my youtube channel and I use it teaching my classes. ive also openly shared placements and aspects in discussions here. love this as a jumping off argument -so curious how others land on this questionJThempowered Astrology + Cocreating@thempoweredBa
@liveyourvoyage I think what I'll also say is part of my value system is in questioning power dynamics. I understand the concept of "professional" but I'm also of the world-building mindset of the village doctor that eats around the fire at night with everyone else. I think that by sharing my patterns, challenges, and struggles openly, others are able to integrate their own as well. There's an undoing of shame, there's a shattering of piety, and of course, all of this comes with protection work on my part.FMariKu@liveyourvoyageBa
@thempowered Iām glad you mentioned the village doctor who eats around the fire at night with everyone else, because I believe weāre coming at this from different angles. A village doctor sees the same people day in and day out. They probably live among them, too. Sharing your life in those circumstances is very different from sharing it with a patient who has just walked into a city doctorās office. The latter doesnāt make much sense. It can also be counterproductive. Most of my clients donāt understand astrological jargon. Some are curious, and I answer their questions. Others just flat-out want a clear interpretation with no astrological vocabulary included. I adjust accordingly. If thereās an educational personal story to share, I share it, including the relevant birth chart placements. Although I wasnāt talking about clients in the first place, but about sharing my chart with the general public.JThempowered Astrology + Cocreating@thempoweredBa
@liveyourvoyage that makes so much sense! i agree that i wouldn't share my chart in a client session 1:1 cuz it isnt about me in that moment and guiding clients is often very focused in the context of the specific reading. That said, in other parts of my work: my writing, my show, my teaching - sharing my chart becomes a helpful anecdotal tool! - J
Hailey@motherofmayhemBa
Me, an 11H libra mars & libra asc, waiting for someone to even disagree with this because youāre not wrong š¤£CLauren Alexandra@wordwitcherBa
@motherofmayhem Venus is backing my Spica Mercury right now and amplifying my middle road, both sides nonsense šJHailey@motherofmayhemBa
@wordwitcher venus is on my ascendant𤣠itās ok Iām gonna pretend this has been pre-approved by the lady herself hahahahamChristine@nightstirringsBa
@motherofmayhem I have an 11th house (Koch) Aries Mars conjoined Eris, so I like to stir the proverbial pot now and then. - C
Gray@graygarlandBa
if ppl are worried about hexing, i think i would just try to be as on top of my energetic hygiene as i could and throw caution to the wind š i used to throw caution to the wind too much and had to up my protection game a bit if ppl are worried about projection, manipulation, all forms of skullduggery that come up in intimate relationships lol, that's a more complicated answer. i, for one, think way too much about transference and countertransference and how most coaches have no idea what that is much less how it may be impacting their efficacy as a coach lol. i imagine the same is true to some extent with astrologers. but also a mentor/mentee type relationship, for example, is so intimate that i think that transparency is necessary. both parties need to put something on the line. sometimes experiences that wound the mentor become teachers for the mentee. and vice versa.CLauren Alexandra@wordwitcherBa
@graygarland the one thing that I think a lot of folks don't recognize when it comes to protection work is that some charts are literally just more susceptible to spiritual harm and more permeable. Comes back to Diana Rose Harper's chart privilege talk for me. I think there can be a dismissiveness on the subject (not that you are doing that here but just in general). There's also the matter that spiritual hygiene and protection work is very resource and energy intensive when done well, and much like wearing protective gear when rock climbing doesn't mean that you aren't taking risks. Life is inherently lethal though so we all choose the risks we are comfortable with. For me it's just about making sure people are actually informed before doing it. The transference and countertransference subject is an interesting one and I hope you will write a post on it because I feel like it goes well beyond the questions I have posed here. I think with astrologers we really need to focus more on praxis with consulting and not just on whether or not we can read the wandering Stars.CGray@graygarlandBa
@wordwitcher that's so interesting. i'm fascinated by this idea of some charts being more permeable than others because i've shown charts for certain events or workings to ppl before where the chart intentionally obfuscated itself, like it had built in mechanisms for it. protection in general is a weak spot for me and that's why i sought out a mentor for mediumship and ancestor work this year!! - F
MariKu@liveyourvoyageBa
I donāt share my chart. I talk about it vaguely and confirm if someone decides to guess a placement (but Iām an unreliable confirmer). I also advise others to keep their charts to themselves. Being nosy as an astrologer and being nosy for the sake of trashing people behind their backs (unfortunately, Iāve met a bunch of these people) are not the same thing. This is a profession, and I keep it professional.CLauren Alexandra@wordwitcherBa
@liveyourvoyage I feel like this argument works better elsewhere. But this is an app by professionals, for professionals, that relies heavily on individual chart data and collective participation. While it is true that disclosure is not technically necessary here and we could just analyze other charts, this app would be immediately and starkly different if no one shared their charts. The camaraderie, shared understanding, exploration, excitement, sense of connection, and trust built by recognizing shared vulnerability would evaporate. Likewise, if no one shared their charts, the profession itself would disappear. It doesn't sit well with me thinking of my clients as taking a risk on me that was foolish because they shouldn't have shared their chart and don't know if they can trust me yet. It is a delicate matter but try as my Scorpio MC might I struggle to believe that absolute secrecy is the healthiest choice (though I have certainly entertained that extreme in the past).FMariKu@liveyourvoyageBa
@wordwitcher Nobody has ever unanimously agreed on anything, nor will they ever. Iām not talking about absolute secrecy, just a general level of privacy. I do share my chart with other astrologers in private settings. Iām just not sure how private this social media platform is going to remain. Iām also not talking about clients. I spend most of my time with non-astrologers who donāt even care about astrology. I assume that has had an impact on how I view this topic.CLauren Alexandra@wordwitcherBa
@liveyourvoyage I am the last person to claim universal consensus is possible. As I noted in the OP, I myself am of split opinions on the matter. But I will say, my walls do to tend go up around those who are extremely guarded with their charts. I've experienced and witnessed the behaviors that tend to follow that stance and it's historically been unpleasant. Obviously that's not going apply to everyone who withholds, and I know several who have very good reasons for doing so. But doing so does create an immediate barrier, especially in a space like this where it is designed for chart integration from the start. Hence why I thought to broach the subject.mChristine@nightstirringsBa
@wordwitcher I have absolutely no fear in sharing my chart. I am at the point in my life where I feel like I am an open book for the most part. I don't feel like anyone can do anything to me using my chart, that I have not already done to myself at some point, and will probably do so again before I die. I welcome what others have to say about my chart. - =
Meghan@torusfieldastrologyBa
I am quite selective about who I share my entire chart, and while certainly I can ward, and I have protection, I have also in the past had people use my chart to siphon my energy, (and one person who still tries to do this, and I have to rework my protection often against him). That person targeted me because of how our charts interact, after years of being stuck in isolation with him, he admitted he saw me like a battery that fuels him (our nodes square). I got more and more sick over time with him. It took divine intervention for me to leave safely with our son, but I did see his energy dissipate when I started consistently calling mine back to me, and setting up protections. When I left I had a dream that he was a Scorpion-shaped demon, with his human face, and he was furiously attempting to reinsert his stinger into my sushumna nadi. He hadnāt just gone for one chakra, like pop spiritualists think, no, he was directly siphoning the divine flow Iāve been cultivating since I was little. He was so mad that he had been detached in the dream, but I was shown that I am free, even if he did retaliate. So, after a few months of observation, I share privately with a select few, with the guidance of my higher self, but not openly.CLauren Alexandra@wordwitcherBa
@torusfieldastrology yiiiikes. That sounds so painful and destabilizing. I'm glad you're free of him.=Meghan@torusfieldastrologyBa
@wordwitcher thank you, Iām glad too. Now I have to walk the line of making sure he stays off our trail while also making sure people are aware that heās using YouTube to find his next victim. š - F
Jessica Lloyce@jessicalloyceworldBa
Hi! Fellow Scorpio MC here š I also take the āstrip teaseā approach (sharing bits and pieces every now and then when relevant/useful but only sharing more details with trusted colleagues). That said, the fundamental question youāre asking feels like (for me) it could be summed up using this metaphor: just because Iāve been in/invited to your house doesnāt mean you are invited into mine. as an astrologer, Iāve been invited into many peopleās housesā¦as the hired help. I do not wish for all my clients or the world to see every nook and cranny of MY house. (Especially given the point you made earlier about how information about my house can be used for malevolent purposes by people who know what to do with that info)CLauren Alexandra@wordwitcherBa
@jessicalloyceworld definitely a fair perspective. I suppose my renewed interest in the question is we're all building this house together but no matter how much I love my roommate, I still don't wanna cosleep... So your metaphor still stands ššš» - C
Katherine@adnastrologicoBa
Im very open with my chart, I donāt care if you ask me about specific placements and we talk about it as long as you share yours too, I respect astrologers who donāt want to share. but I donāt believe in using birth charts to send you bad energy or bad magic or whatever, I donāt even know about that kind of topic, since I have a very logic mind when it comes to beliefs, could be my ( Fj talking, also I believe I have a good discernment about which interpretations are actually on point personality wise, and which ones are just astropop prediction fear mongering and I just ignore those people who talk like that about my chart