Post

@adnastrologico

C
KatherineAfBaOl

@adnastrologico

I’ve been thinking about language lately, which one should be the right way to say it?

22 votes15 hours left

Ba171 Views

Join the conversation. Sign in to reply.

12 replies

  • F

    Jessica Lloyce@jessicalloyceworldBa

    So in practice, I don’t care what people say. But in theory, I feel like this gets at a fundamental question of where/how psychology/pathology is intertwined with astrology. I feel like the most “neutral” way to express this is to say “I was born under Virgo sun” as it doesn’t “overly” emphasize the Virgo sun placement as an identity (as if it was your only or main identity vs everything else in your chart, not just your planetary placements but the aspects (or not!) between them). To say I “have” a Virgo sun is cool I think as a second best option (first being “I was born under”) because it kinda feels like it’s something you have in your bag/arsenal but doesn’t imply it’s the only thing or the most important thing. If I say I have a red shirt (or perhaps a better analogy would be if I say all my shirts are red) no one should reasonably think that means I don’t have blue pants. I’m just telling you one part of my wardrobe. Saying I “am” a red shirt feels like unless you’re out here Winnie the Pooh-ing it 24/7 there would always be broader clothing context to your overall outfit (life/psychology/life experience/pathology/how people tend to experience you/etc) so exclusively stating your shirt color is at best incomplete and at worst, misguided. As in case you haven’t guessed by now I have a heavy Aquarius and Virgo vibe in my chart 😅
    I

    Nookie@your_hood_asstrologistBa

    C

    Katherine@adnastrologicoBa

    @jessicalloyceworld yesss that’s what I’m talking about! Thanks for describing it better than I could. It’s just easy to say I am o I have, but I feel like the more we say I am, the more difficult would be to detach from it, and the idea is to transcend from our birth chart, this is just the energy we experiencing the life with but it’s not ultimately who we are
    F

    Jessica Lloyce@jessicalloyceworldBa

    @adnastrologico your original question reminded me a lot of how in some languages the direct translation is “I have” something that in English we would I say “I am”. Such as in Spanish the direct translation is I have cold vs I am cold in English. I can’t remember which ones but I think some languages say “I have sadness” vs I am sad in English. All this reminds me of work I’ve done in therapy (and what I’ve read about where cultures with more words for a color or natural phenomenon such as snow are better at differentiating between types of snow or shades of that color) that reminds me that language is SO powerful in how it shapes your mind. So to say “I AM a Virgo sun” is kinda like you sure about that buddy? All the good AND the challenges that come with that? That’s the primary lens you want to see yourself through…
    F

    Jessica Lloyce@jessicalloyceworldBa

    Vs having a more expansive sense of self that has room to hold all that you are (for example a Virgo sun in the 8th house conjunct Mercury opposing Mars etc etc etc). But again, this is purely theoretical for me. I do not, nor do I care to, “correct” people when they talk about their placements. That said, I personally have been trying to move away from saying “I am” and more consistently say “I have a” when discussing my own astrology but sometimes I don’t and ultimately it doesn’t matter that much (probably 🫣)
    F

    Jessica Lloyce@jessicalloyceworldBa

    But I also think this gets into how I (and I’d imagine most other self-identifying astrologers) see each sign as an energy. Like when I use “Virgo” in a sentence I’m talking about Virgo as an energy that can exist in any house and have any planet within it vs the general public saying “Virgo” they almost exclusively mean Virgo sun sign energy. So really if you say “I’m a Virgo” I understand in pop culture that means you have a Virgo sun, but really we should all be responding with “a virgo what?” You know?
  • B

    Words of Algol@wordsofalgolBa

    I prefer to say "I have a Virgo Sun" because I don't want to completely identify with a placement. In my perspective it's a pattern and it's also up to me how I live it, so it's more "I'm not my chart, my chart is part of me" But to be honest both are fine, what matters it's that it feels right to you
    C

    Katherine@adnastrologicoBa

    @wordsofalgol my chart is part of me!!! Love that, totally agree
  • G

    Alissa@saturnine_astroBa

    As a living talisman of the moment of my birth, I think both make sense...I have the Moon in Virgo in my natal chart, so I am a Virgo Moon 🌘
  • i

    Gabylon@gabylonBa

    Both make sense to me, depends on the person’s relationship to the “self”, imo :)
  • I

    Nookie@your_hood_asstrologistBa

    I have the Sun in Virgo, I am a Solar Virgo
  • a

    Elisabeth Grace@whynownewsBa

    Your query made me smile. Imagine a Virgo wondering about the correct way to talk about the placement of their Sun...no, really, a VIRGO. FWIW, my preference would be be "I have Sun in Virgo" or "I'm a Virgo"...and obviously I have planets in Gemini, since I'm giving you two options. Astrology is amazing :)