A deep wish that should not be controversial: I so truly hope this space can forever hold this early beauty, this early generosity and care, this collegiality, never spiral into a space defined by cliques that treat others with unkindness or incessant self-promotion, as it seems every other space, even some classes, have become.
There's a delicate balance between creating cliques vs groups/cohorts. While I agree that the astrology world can become very unkind, having watched it rebuild itself on threads over the last few years, with people saying it's cliquish, I don't know that I agree. Instead, I've watched friends and colleagues group together through shared activities and experiences. You can invite someone in who hasn't done the things you have, but the connections won't form the same way as someone who went through things with you. Groups also naturally develop based on the type of astrology one uses. Having to adjust and translate between different systems can create distance. There's also something to be said of synastry. The millennial hJ and j placements, for example tend to have social staying power with each other in a way I haven't seen in other age groups.
So while I do agree that we should keep the enthusiasm and inclusiveness we're generating now, humans do naturally section themselves off, simply because intimacy cannot exist in a massive crowd, nor can real understanding. This is a digital city. We can visit each other and work together, but folks are going to settle down in different neighborhoods. I think that is normal but if we try to keep everyone together on the same level as now we're going to fail because there's going to be too many of us before we know it. It's a particularly potent subject for me as someone with the strongest and most aggressively OOS malefic ruling my 11h with J there t 8h D. I've been through a lot of group/relational trauma, bullying and upheaval. But the astrology world is the first place I've ever actually felt at home. Conflicts have and will continue to happen, and people will not like each other. That doesn't mean we can't build together. And I think this place gives us a very unique opportunity since astrologers are the ground floor here. May the stars continue to be what unites us 🙏🏻
@wordwitcher, thank you for sharing your experiences. It's so fascinating to me how differently I feel about the possibilities multipliticities of astrologies and perspectives represents, how much potential for joyous collaboration and connection there exists, an expansiveness rather than the narrowing you suggest almost an inevitability--and, yes, I am sure this reflects, to give one for instance, my Jupiter in Gemini, my Uranus in the seventh opposite Mercury (which, of course, rules the Jupiter, and has some reception with it)... It is a gorgeous ideal I hold, but, you are right, I am often deeply, deeply disappointed by how rarely this manifests (or how often it's revealed to me that where I believed generosity there was secret pettiness I was stunned by, as when I was in a playwriting unit and imagined only love and respect between us, what I experienced, and had to be told this was not the truth of it), a source of sadness many times in my life when I hoped for community across difference and was disillusioned instead.
@venusianrevolution I am a fellow cF but in the 6h ruling my chart ruler, iGoH. So for me, there is a strong sense of the labor and cost of multiplicity. It's not to say collaboration isn't worth it, but that everyone involved needs to be on the same page with expectations and desires from the start if the collaboration is to be fruitful more often than not. When there isn't shared understanding, you can still learn a lot but people have to be willing to do so, so I think it's better to be upfront with those expectations as it can save heartache. I definitely love cross-pollination and different schools of thought working together. In my communication and group studies background though, I still find consistently that people will head home to the people they share the most with, hence folks grouping together.
I also love virtue ethics, which is aspirational. Having a horizon we can never reach is how we keep doing better, so your views aren't wrong, it's just a matter of making sure you don't expect them to be fulfilled as it could leave you with the heartache that you've experienced already. They are incredibly inspiring though and will lead to better little by little as you voice them 💜 Can I ask what's going on with your Venus?
@wordwitcher, my chart is on my profile, should you wish to apply your own lens. I am deeply comfortable in my skin, with who I am, so even when others are forceful in imposing their own opinions on my chart, on my beingness I am able to receive them and hold myself, both.
@venusianrevolution so my first thought going to your profile and seeing your big three was "Holy Taurus!" Username checks out 😂 but it looks like you don't have your chart set to public. I was a little confused by this as well because it will show all of our birth data to us, but if you scroll down it'll show what you have set to public and not. Looks like you have your join chart set but I'm not seeing the natal. I was just curious where you're Venus is in relation to all of the lush Taurus being ruled and if there are aspects to the Jupiter at all that could contribute to your embodied generosity of Spirit and the way that you think the best of others but don't always find it reciprocated. Maybe a malefic Venus contact?
Also kudos on you for being open. The nature of my chart does not sit well in the public eye, particularly with Neptune conjunct the ascendant under a degree, so I end up feeling very permeable, and my detriment Moon can't always handle what other people put on me. I'm pretty free with sharing details but not the whole picture except in private, in which case my Leo Venus has given my chart to way too many people lolol
@wordwitcher, I do, yes--that the most succinct answer all of your questions. (Laughs) And, perhaps, this.
Edit: That is it, I am just unaccustomed to seeing those aspect lines. It must be the current settings.
@venusianrevolution awwww she's just a 12h girlie dreaming of a better world. It's an interesting reception between Venus and Mars too, though they can't see each other. Almost feels like there's probably this innate knowing but disconnect, which seems like what you were describing earlier. I loooove Aries Venus though as an Aries Mars/Leo Venus. There's an effortless way of being and connecting to it, though unfortunately, the detriment does seem to come out consistently in other people not being able to show up the same way.
@wordwitcher, I experience my Venus and Mars in deep communion, each integrated, whole, the masculine in the feminine, the feminine in the masculine, an inner marriage--if, yes, they've separate homes, she a room in his, he in hers. Venus, though, while my ASC ruler, does answer to Mars, who answers to that Jupiter (widely sextile Venus), who answers to the Mercury on the ASC, who must consult with Venus... It is experienced as an alignment of conscious and unconscious parts of self. She's less in detriment that she appears, and she is often met, that placement representative. But, she does know--I do acknowledge--that with aspects like those you asked about, to Jupiter (wide), to Neptune (wide), to Saturn, and to Pluto, she is not easily met. Perhaps, this why she is as happy in her turret in the tower of the twelfth doing her creative work, her tantric practices, etc., etc.
I appreciate, truly, your perspectives, as your analysis, however different, as before suggested--I sense this is a sharing you truly revel in, or I do hope it is.
@venusianrevolution ahh. Interesting. I'm running around doing things so I didn't do a deep look at the chart but the dispositor loop makes a lot of sense. Like a council meeting by letter and everyone has to read and respond to each other before motion, but it sounds like you are very at ease in the system and made it work for you.
And yes, I do love the sharing. I am overwhelmed that we have a space like this to do it in. Thank you for letting me sit with your chart 💜